Greg Ichshenko

Calgary SEO expert and digital marketing specialist,
developing advertising strategies for businesses of all sizes

(403) 308-5949

greg@to-the-top.ca
1509 14 Ave SW, Calgary,
AB T3C 0W4

    Submit your request or question, and I will get back
    to you shortly

    Does URL Affect SEO?

    A URL affects SEO, but far less through its keywords than most people assume. Google’s SEO Starter Guide says that keywords in the domain name or URL path alone have hardly any effect beyond appearing in breadcrumbs, so a keyword-rich address will not lift a page on its own. Where URLs do matter is in the plumbing: a messy URL scheme can make Google crawl a site inefficiently, create many addresses for the same page, and turn a redesign into a ranking dip if old addresses are changed without care. The sections below separate the small direct effect from those indirect ones, using Google’s own documentation.

    A man lays out a breadcrumb path from Home to Category, Subcategory, Product and Page

    What Google says about URLs and rankings

    Google’s documentation treats URLs in two separate ways. For ranking, the Starter Guide lists keywords in the domain name or URL path under things not to focus on, and says they have hardly any effect beyond breadcrumbs. For crawling and for people, the same guide recommends descriptive URLs, because parts of a URL can be shown in search results as breadcrumbs and a searcher can use them to judge whether a result will be useful. A URL made only of random identifiers, it says, is less helpful for users.

    The second document that matters is Google’s URL structure guide, last updated in October 2026. It sets out requirements for a crawlable URL structure and warns that if a site’s URLs do not meet them, Google will likely crawl the site inefficiently, and that is the real risk. A URL rarely helps a good page rank higher, but a URL scheme that generates endless variations of the same content can waste Google’s crawling on pages nobody needs and leave important pages less well covered.

    The domain name works the same way. The Starter Guide says to choose a domain for business reasons, since keywords in it have hardly any ranking effect, and that the top-level domain only matters when a site targets one country, where it is usually a low-impact signal. For a Calgary business that serves Canadians, a .ca is a sensible choice, but it is not a ranking lever, and there is more on whether a domain name affects SEO in a separate article. HTTPS is different, because Google announced it as a ranking signal in 2014 while describing it as very lightweight, and today it is one of the page experience factors Google lists.

    A man stands beside a signpost, choosing which way to go

    URL property Effect on ranking Effect on crawling, indexing or clicks
    Keywords in the path Hardly any, per Google, beyond breadcrumbs Helps searchers, and readers of a shared link, see what the page is about
    Keywords in the domain Hardly any, per Google None directly; choose the name for the business
    Country domain such as .ca Usually a low-impact country signal Helps when the site targets one country
    HTTPS A lightweight signal, now part of page experience Browsers warn visitors about insecure pages
    Unneeded parameters, session IDs None directly Can create large numbers of duplicate URLs and waste crawling
    Changing an existing URL Temporary fluctuation while Google reprocesses Needs a permanent redirect and time

    Keywords in the URL: one clear word beats five

    Because Google gives URL keywords so little weight, the case for them is about people rather than rankings. A path such as /furnace-repair/ tells a searcher, a colleague reading a shared link and anyone linking to the page what it is about before they click. When another site pastes the bare URL as the link text, as some forums and directories do, a descriptive path also tells readers of that page where the link goes, which a string of numbers would not.

    That argument runs out quickly. Repeating the same term in the domain, folder and slug, such as /calgary-plumber/calgary-plumbing/calgary-plumber-services/, reads as spam to people, and Google’s Starter Guide notes that excessively repeating words is tiring for users and that keyword stuffing is against its spam policies. A few words that describe the page, in the language the audience searches in, are enough.

    A man pins the word Keyword on a board of SEO terms such as URL, slug, path and relevance

    Dates and numbers deserve a second thought. A slug such as /7-tips-for-winter-roofing/ goes stale the moment the article grows to nine tips, and a date in a blog path can make evergreen content look old wherever the address is shown, including shared links. If the content will be updated over time, leave the number and the date out. For the practical steps, from picking the words to setting up WordPress permalinks, there is a separate guide on how to build SEO-friendly URLs.

    How long should a URL be?

    Google does not publish a length target for URLs, and none of its documentation calls length a ranking factor. Its URL structure guide asks for something more useful: use readable words rather than long ID numbers, and use as few parameters as you can, trimming any that do not change the content. The character limits that circulate online are rules of thumb, not Google requirements.

    A man points at an arrow in the centre of a target

    A shorter URL still has practical advantages. It is easier to read out over the phone, to put on a truck wrap or a business card, and to paste into an email without it breaking across lines. The sensible rule is to make the URL as short as it can be while still describing the page, and to remove folders and words that add length without adding meaning, as long as the address stays clear.

    Hyphens, lowercase and the reader’s language

    Google recommends hyphens to separate words, because they help users and search engines identify concepts in the URL. Its guide explains that underscores are commonly used to keep concepts together, as in programming function names such as format_date, while hyphens clearly signal a word boundary. Joining words with no separator at all, as in /greendress, is also on its list of things not to do.

    A runner breaks the finish-line tape ahead of three others

    Case is easy to overlook. Google treats URLs as case sensitive, so /Services/ and /services/ are two different addresses as far as it is concerned, each with its own content. If a web server serves the same page for both, Google’s guide recommends converting everything to one case, and lowercase is the usual choice because people type it naturally.

    Language matters for Canadian sites with a French audience. Google’s guide says to use words in the audience’s language in the URL, so a French page can use a French slug rather than an English one. Where a word contains an accented letter, Google recommends percent-encoding it in the links on the site, which means /rénovation appears in the HTML as /r%C3%A9novation. Most content management systems handle this automatically, but it is worth checking after a migration or a plugin change.

    Parameters, folders and crawling

    Parameters are the part after the question mark, such as ?sort=price or ?sessionid=6EE2BF. Google’s URL structure guide names the usual troublemakers: filters that can be combined in many ways, sorting and referral parameters, session IDs and calendars that link to endless future dates. Each combination becomes a separate URL showing the same or nearly the same content, and the guide warns that this can make Googlebot use far more bandwidth than necessary or leave Google unable to index all of a site’s content. It suggests cookies instead of session IDs, and robots.txt for blocking URLs generated on the fly, such as internal search results.

    A man turns an orange gear that drives a set of larger gears

    Paid traffic adds parameters of its own. Google Ads auto-tagging, which is on by default for new accounts, adds a GCLID parameter to the landing page URL after an ad click, so a page such as example.com/furnace-repair/ is reached as example.com/furnace-repair/?gclid=123xyz. Google Ads Help notes that a small number of sites serve an error page when they see unfamiliar parameters, and that sites using redirects need to pass the GCLID through to the final landing page or conversion tracking suffers. Anyone running Google Ads campaigns to pages they also want to rank should check both, and make sure each landing page, including its GCLID version, returns a canonical tag naming the clean address.

    Folders raise a different question, and Google’s Starter Guide says that for sites with more than a few thousand URLs, grouping similar topics in directories can help Google learn how often each section changes and crawl them at different rates. A small business site with fifty pages will not see much difference, which is why the question of grouping pages into folders has a different answer for a shop with thousands of products than for a service business.

    Duplicate URLs and canonical tags

    The same page can often be reached at several addresses: with and without www, over http and https, with and without a trailing slash, and with any number of tracking parameters added. Google’s Starter Guide is calm about this. Duplicate content on a site is not a violation of its spam policies and will not cause a manual action, but it can be a poor experience for users and can waste crawling on URLs that do not matter. If a site does not choose a canonical URL itself, Google will try to choose one.

    A man types on a laptop as a page marked Duplicate comes out of it

    Leaving that choice to Google works most of the time, but it means the version shown in search results may not be the one the site owner prefers. Google’s canonical documentation lists the ways to state a preference: a redirect is a strong signal that its target should be canonical, a rel=”canonical” link is also a strong signal, and inclusion in a sitemap is a weak one. These signals add up when they agree. The practical setup for most sites is one permanent redirect to the preferred host and protocol, a self-referencing canonical tag on every page, and a sitemap that lists only the canonical URLs. Search Console’s page indexing report lists the URLs Google has set aside as duplicates, and the URL Inspection tool shows which canonical Google chose for a given page.

    Should you change URLs for SEO?

    Usually not. A 2022 Search Engine Land article on this question quotes John Mueller of Google, who, as reported by Search Engine Roundtable, summed up changing URLs for SEO reasons as “Some risk + usually no gain.” The one possible exception he mentioned was URLs so bad that people cannot even copy and paste them. Given that keywords in a URL have hardly any ranking effect, rewriting a working, readable address to add a keyword trades a known risk for a gain Google says barely exists.

    A man posts a letter into a mailbox marked 301

    There are good reasons to change URLs, and they are rarely about keywords: moving to HTTPS, consolidating two pages on the same topic, replacing an old platform whose addresses are long strings of IDs, or merging a site after a rebrand. In each case, Google recommends a permanent server-side redirect (301 or 308) from the old URL to the new one, which tells Google to show the new address in search results. The redirect should go straight to the final page, since Google’s site-move guide advises against chained redirects.

    As for timing, Google’s site-move guide says rankings may fluctuate while it recrawls and reindexes, that a medium-sized site can take a few weeks or more before the new URLs replace the old ones in results, and that larger sites take longer. It recommends keeping redirects for at least a year so Google can transfer signals, including links from other sites, and suggests that from a user’s point of view they can stay indefinitely. Any change that touches more than a handful of pages is worth treating as a project, so it pays to plan the move as an SEO migration, with a full list of old and new addresses before anything goes live.

    A quick check for your own site

    Sites built on WordPress or a similar platform usually start with readable URLs, although permalink, category and plugin settings can still create extra versions, so the check is less about rewriting addresses and more about finding leaks. The questions below cover the issues Google’s documentation actually warns about, and Search Console plus a browser can answer most of them.

    • Does every version of the home page (http, https, with and without www) end up at one address after a single redirect?
    • Does each page carry a canonical tag pointing to its own clean URL?
    • Does the page indexing report in Search Console show large numbers of duplicate or alternate URLs, and are they parameter versions?
    • Do any internal links point to URLs that redirect, rather than straight to the final address?
    • If you run Google Ads, does a test click with a GCLID added load the page normally, and does the GCLID survive any redirect?
    • Are URLs consistently lowercase, with hyphens between words?

    If every answer is yes, the URLs are unlikely to be what is holding the site back, and the time is better spent on the content and the links that point to it. If you would like a second opinion on what the checks turn up, SEO Company To-The-TOP! is a Calgary practice that has worked on search since 2007, and you can reach it through the To-The-TOP! home page or by calling (403) 308-5949.

    Contact Calgary SEO Company To-The-TOP!

    Questions about anything in this article, or about your own rankings? Talk to a Calgary SEO specialist directly.

    Phone: (403) 308-5949
    Address: 1509 14 Ave SW, Calgary, AB T3C 0W4

    Hours:
    Monday to Friday: 10:00 am – 7:00 pm
    Saturday: 12:00 pm – 4:00 pm
    Sunday: closed