How to Choose the Best SEO Company When WebpageFX Is on Your Shortlist

WebpageFX now operates as WebFX, and webpagefx.com redirects to webfx.com, so any comparison starts with the current company. To choose the best SEO company with WebFX on your list, match the agency’s model to the size of your business. As of October 2026, WebFX publishes SEO plans from $2,900 to $9,200 a month on a six-month commitment, each with a dedicated account manager. If your budget and goals fit that structure, it is a serious candidate, and if you run a single-location business in Calgary, compare it with what local specialists publish and put the same questions from Google’s hiring guidance to every option.
Who WebFX is, from its own pages
The quickest way to judge a large agency is to read what it says about itself and check whether that matches what you need. WebFX’s About page says the company was founded in 1996 and lists 750 experts on staff, and its SEO pricing page is unusually open for an agency of its size, because it prints a full plan table rather than asking you to call for a quote. That openness is useful: you can see the entry price, the commitment and how the account is staffed before you ever speak to a salesperson.
| What WebFX publishes | As of 2026-10-31 |
|---|---|
| Company age | Founded 1996 (About page) |
| Staff | “750 experts on staff” (About page) |
| SEO plans | Silver $2,900, Silver Plus $4,200, Gold $6,150, Platinum $7,400, Diamond $9,200 a month |
| Commitment | “6-month commitment” on every plan |
| Who you deal with | A “Dedicated WebFX Revenue Marketing Account Manager” in every plan, backed by specialist teams |
| Smallest budget on its proposal form | $2,500 to $5,000 a month |
| Currency | Plan prices carry no currency label; the proposal form is set up in US dollars |
The account manager line matters more than it looks. It tells you that your day-to-day contact is backed by specialist teams, which is the normal model for an agency with hundreds of staff and is neither good nor bad on its own. What it changes is the question you ask in the sales call: who, by role, will write the content, change the pages and build the links on your site, and how you will hear from them.

What WebFX’s own guide tells you to check
Some people who search for this topic are likely looking for WebFX’s own article on choosing an SEO company, which it last updated in September 2026. Its six steps are sensible: define your goals and budget, research companies across several channels, check experience in your industry, read case studies, assess communication, and review the agency’s technology. Its red flags are also sound, including guaranteed rankings, generic one-size-fits-all strategies, vague reporting and outdated tactics such as mass link building.
The guide is written by an agency that sells SEO, though, and it is worth reading with that in mind. Its examples are WebFX’s own case studies and a Clutch ranking it highlights, and its closing section is a pitch for WebFX’s services. That does not make the advice wrong, but it does mean two checks that Google puts to every candidate are missing from the list: experience in your own city and how much access to give an agency during an audit. For a fuller checklist that does not come from one vendor, see the separate guide on how to choose the right SEO company.
What the guide leaves out, and Google does not
Google’s own page for people hiring help, “Do you need an SEO?” (last updated June 2026), covers ground the WebFX guide skips. It suggests asking every candidate “What’s your experience in my country/city?”, which is a fair test for any agency, large or small, that wants your Calgary or Edmonton business. It also says that if an SEO offers an audit, you should grant only read access to Search Console at that stage, and it backs up WebFX’s own warning about guarantees in plainer terms: “No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google.” Google even says that a small local business can probably do much of the work itself, which is a useful reality check before you sign any six-month agreement.

Questions to put to WebFX and every other candidate
Asking the same questions of every company is what turns a shortlist into a comparison, because a polished proposal from one agency and a short phone call with another are otherwise hard to weigh against each other. The list below combines Google’s interview questions with the points that a published six-month commitment raises.
- Who, by name or at least by role, will make the changes to my site each month, and will I ever speak to that person directly?
- What is your experience with businesses in my city and my industry, and can you show me examples?
- What exactly is included at the plan level you are recommending, and what costs extra?
- What happens at the end of the commitment: does the plan renew automatically, and on what notice can I leave?
- Who owns the content, the Search Console property, the Google Business Profile and the analytics account if the engagement ends?
- Will you share every change you make to the site, with the reasoning behind it?
- What results do you expect, over what timeframe, and how will you measure them?
Any agency that answers these clearly is worth considering, whatever its size. An agency that dodges the ownership question or promises a ranking position has told you what you need to know.
Running the numbers in Canadian dollars
For a Canadian business, the plan prices need one more step before they mean anything. If WebFX’s figures are in US dollars, as its form setup suggests, the Silver plan at $2,900 a month comes to about $4,050 Canadian at the Bank of Canada rate of 1.3960 published for 30 October 2026. Over the six-month commitment, that is roughly $24,300 Canadian before any tax, and the exchange rate will move during the term. This is an illustrative calculation, not a quote, so ask WebFX to confirm the currency and the total in writing.
Local figures give you something to set that against. In the review of prices Calgary agencies publish on their own websites (August 2026), the lowest monthly figure each agency published for SEO, a mix of prices, minimums and statements of what clients typically spend, had a median of $1,000 across seven agencies. Those are starting points rather than like-for-like plans, and the scope behind each one differs, so the useful comparison is what each provider would actually do for your site at the price, which the review lets you check agency by agency.

None of this says a higher price is a bad deal. A larger plan can include design, conversion work and content teams that a small provider does not offer, and if you need those, a single contract may save you time. The same reasoning applies to other large names, such as Neil Patel’s agency, where the structure of the engagement matters as much as the monthly figure.
When a large agency fits and when a specialist does
The decision is mostly about the shape of your business rather than about which company is better in the abstract. A large agency is built for coordination across many services and markets, while a specialist is built for depth on a narrower problem. The table below is a rule of thumb, not a verdict on any agency.
| Your situation | A large multi-service agency such as WebFX | A local specialist |
|---|---|---|
| Many locations or several countries | Built for this; ask who covers each market | Ask whether it has the capacity |
| You want SEO, design, content and paid ads under one contract | Often the simpler choice | Usually covers fewer services |
| One location, one main market such as Calgary | Can work, but check who does the work and the minimum spend | Worth comparing on the same questions |
| Budget below the smallest band on the agency’s proposal form | Likely below its target client | Worth comparing |
| You want to speak to the person changing your site | Ask how the account manager model handles this | Ask whether that person does the work |

Where a Calgary specialist fits
SEO Company To-The-TOP! is the specialist end of that table. It is a Calgary-based solo practice founded in 2007, so one person does the strategy, the work on your site and the reporting, with no handoff to junior staff. It works White Hat only, reports keyword positions monthly and keeps a public portfolio of ranked keywords you can check before you call. It serves Calgary, Edmonton, Vancouver and the rest of Alberta and British Columbia.
To-The-TOP! is also Google Ads certified, so Google Ads management sits with the same person who handles the organic side. Because it is a solo practice, the person who prices the work is the person who does it, and with any provider, To-The-TOP! included, ask for the management fee and any ad spend as two separate numbers before you compare offers.

The short version
WebFX is a large, long-established agency that publishes its plan prices, which lets you evaluate it before you ask for a proposal. Choose it if you need its breadth and its plans fit your budget, and look closer to home if you are a single-location business that wants direct contact with the person doing the work. Either way, ask every candidate the same questions, confirm the currency and the total commitment in writing, and keep ownership of your accounts. To ask what your project would cost with To-The-TOP!, or for a second opinion on a proposal you already have, call (403) 308-5949.
Contact Calgary SEO Company To-The-TOP!
Questions about anything in this article, or about your own rankings? Talk to a Calgary SEO specialist directly.
Phone: (403) 308-5949
Address: 1509 14 Ave SW, Calgary, AB T3C 0W4
Hours:
Monday to Friday: 10:00 am – 7:00 pm
Saturday: 12:00 pm – 4:00 pm
Sunday: closed
