Greg Ichshenko

Calgary SEO expert and digital marketing specialist,
developing advertising strategies for businesses of all sizes

(403) 308-5949

greg@to-the-top.ca
1509 14 Ave SW, Calgary,
AB T3C 0W4

    Submit your request or question, and I will get back
    to you shortly

    Do SEO Services Work?

    Yes, SEO services do work, but only under four conditions: people actually search for what you sell; the provider, or someone on your side, can make changes to your website and, for a local business, your Google Business Profile; the gap between you and the businesses already ranking can be closed with the time and budget you have; and the work follows Google’s rules. When one of those is missing, a good provider cannot make up for it. Google’s own guidance on hiring an SEO puts the trade-off plainly: a provider “can potentially improve your site’s visibility and save you time, but you can also risk damage to your site and reputation.” This page explains what decides which of those you get, and how to check.

    A business owner shaking hands with an SEO provider

    What an SEO service actually changes

    An SEO provider cannot change how Google ranks pages. What it can change is your site and the signals around it, so that Google’s systems find your pages more relevant and useful for the searches your customers make. Google says its ranking systems look at many factors, including “the words of your query, relevance and usability of pages, expertise of sources, and your location and settings.” Google’s page on hiring an SEO lists useful services a provider can offer, including a review of your site’s content or structure, technical advice on things like hosting, redirects, error pages and JavaScript, content development, keyword research, training, expertise in specific markets, and optimizing for generative AI.

    It is worth knowing what is not on that list. Google states that advertising with Google “won’t have any effect on your site’s presence” in its search results, and that it never accepts money to include or rank sites. If you also run Google Ads, that spend can bring visits, but it does not lift your organic position, so a report that blends paid and organic clicks is not telling you whether the SEO works. For a Calgary business that serves customers in the map results, the same rule applies there. Google’s Business Profile help says “There’s no way to request or pay for a better local ranking on Google,” and that local results are “mainly based on relevance, distance, and popularity.” A provider can improve relevance by completing your profile and matching it to your site, and can help with popularity through links and a steady habit of asking customers for reviews, but nobody can move your business closer to the person searching.

    So “working” has a specific meaning. The pages a provider improves should start appearing for more searches that people outside your existing customer base type, then rank higher for the searches that bring buyers, and eventually produce calls, form submissions or bookings that you can count. Rankings on phrases nobody searches, or traffic from people who could never become customers, do not count, however good the chart looks.

    A business owner putting a coin into an ads machine

    When SEO services tend to work, and when they cannot

    Most of the debate about whether SEO works comes from people describing different situations. The table sets out the conditions that usually decide the outcome, based on practice rather than any published Google rule.

    Condition SEO services tend to work when SEO services cannot do much when
    Search demand People search for your service in the areas you serve Customers do not search for what you sell, or only search your competitors’ brand names
    Access The provider can edit pages, fix technical problems and manage the Business Profile, or you make the changes promptly Recommendations sit in a report because nobody can change the site
    Competitive gap Your targets are specific services and locations a site of your size can reach A young site with few links targets the most contested phrase in its industry
    Methods Content, technical fixes and links follow Google’s spam policies Links are bought or traded to pass ranking credit, or pages are mass-produced to target search terms
    Timing The business can wait months for organic results The business needs leads this month, which is a job for advertising

    An illustrative example shows how this plays out. A Calgary furnace repair company with a slow site, thin service pages and an incomplete Business Profile is in a good position, because there is clear local demand and plenty that can be fixed. A new online store hoping to rank across Canada for a single-word product term against national retailers is in a much weaker one, even with a capable provider. The services are the same in both cases, and the results are not. If you are weighing Calgary SEO services for your own business, start by deciding which column you are in.

    Mapping local search demand in Calgary

    Why SEO services fail

    The most common failure is targeting the wrong searches. A provider that promises to rank a small site for a broad, highly competitive term sets the campaign up to look like it failed, even if the work is sound. Starting with specific services, locations and questions that buyers actually type, and widening the targets as the site earns visibility, is slower to sell but far more likely to produce results.

    The second failure is work that never reaches the site. Audits and recommendations do nothing until someone implements them, and many small businesses sign up for SEO on a website platform or with a web developer that makes changes difficult. Before you hire anyone, settle who can edit the site and how quickly changes go live.

    The third is shortcuts. Google’s spam policies treat link spam, including “Buying or selling links for ranking purposes,” as a violation, along with scaled content created mainly to manipulate rankings. Sites that break those policies can rank lower or not appear in results at all, and Google can apply a manual action that shows up in the Manual actions report in Search Console. A provider whose results depend on links it will not describe is taking that risk with your domain, not its own.

    The last common failure is a mismatch in expectations. Some owners stop before the work has had time to show anything, and some providers keep billing for months while reporting activity rather than results. Both problems shrink when the expected results and the timeframe are written down at the start. If a site has stalled for reasons that have nothing to do with the provider, the guide to the reasons SEO stalls on a particular site covers the technical and competitive causes.

    How long SEO services take to work

    Google does not give a fixed timeline for SEO, and any fixed number would mislead, because the answer depends on how competitive your searches are, the state of the site and how much work is in scope. Its SEO Starter Guide says only that some changes “might take effect in a few hours, others could take several months.” What Google does suggest is asking a prospective provider, “What kind of results do you expect to see, and in what timeframe?” A good provider answers that for your situation, in writing, before you sign.

    As practitioner guidance for a typical small business site rather than a promise, the early months usually go to fixing technical problems, improving or creating the main service pages and getting them indexed. Movement on specific, less contested searches tends to come next, often within several months, while competitive terms in a large market can take a year or more. A Business Profile that was incomplete can sometimes respond sooner than the website, because the fixes are smaller. If a long stretch passes with no movement on indexing, impressions or positions for the pages that were worked on, and the provider cannot explain why using your data, the timeline is no longer the issue.

    Waiting for SEO results takes months

    How to check that the work is working

    You do not have to take a provider’s report on trust, because the data that matters sits in accounts your business should own. Make sure your business owns its Google Search Console property and its Business Profile, keeps an Administrator of its own on its Google Analytics account, and adds the provider as a user with only the access it needs. Search Console has an owner role with full control, a full user role that can view all data and take some actions, and a restricted user role that “Has simple view rights on most data.” Google’s hiring guidance goes further for the early stage, telling owners to give a provider offering an audit only “read access to Search Console (at this stage, don’t grant them write access).”

    With access in your hands, three checks tell you most of what you need. In the Search Console Performance report, filter out searches for your business name and compare impressions and clicks for the pages the provider worked on against the period before the work began. Ask for a monthly list of changes with the URL of each, then open a few of those pages to confirm the work is there. Finally, confirm that calls, forms or bookings from organic search are being counted, because rankings and traffic are only steps toward enquiries. The guide to checking an SEO company’s work month by month walks through each of these in detail.

    Red flags, and where to complain in Canada

    Google’s page on hiring an SEO is direct about guarantees: “No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google.” It also warns against providers who claim a “special relationship” with Google, advertise a “priority submit” to Google, or are secretive about what they intend to do. A provider that guarantees a position by a date is promising something it does not control, and if one is offered, ask how many people search each guaranteed phrase, because a ranking nobody searches for brings no customers.

    If you believe an SEO provider misled you, Google’s page points US complaints to the Federal Trade Commission and complaints about companies elsewhere to econsumer.gov. In Canada, the Competition Bureau explains that under the Competition Act “it is against the law to advertise or market something in a way that is false or misleading,” which covers marketing claims made by SEO providers like anyone else. Keep the proposal, the contract and the reports, because they show what was promised if you ever need to make a complaint.

    Do it yourself, or hire a provider?

    Google’s answer for small businesses may surprise people who expect a sales pitch: “If you run a small local business, you can probably do much of the work yourself,” starting with its SEO Starter Guide. That is a fair starting point. An owner who has the time to write good service pages, keep the Business Profile complete and ask customers for reviews can cover a lot of ground without paying anyone.

    Hiring makes more sense when time is the constraint, when the site has technical problems you cannot diagnose, when you are planning a redesign or a new site (Google calls that “a great time to hire,” the earlier the better), or when competitors have pulled ahead on searches that bring them real work. Even then, knowing the basics helps, because Google notes that it lets you spot a technique that is not recommended before it is used on your site.

    Rising above local competitors in search

    SEO Company To-The-TOP! has worked in Calgary since 2007 as a solo practice, so one expert does the client work from start to finish, using White Hat methods only and reporting positions monthly. Its public portfolio of ranked keywords shows the searches it has worked on. If you would like a second opinion on whether SEO can work for your business, or on a proposal you already have, call (403) 308-5949.

    Contact Calgary SEO Company To-The-TOP!

    Questions about anything in this article, or about your own rankings? Talk to a Calgary SEO specialist directly.

    Phone: (403) 308-5949
    Address: 1509 14 Ave SW, Calgary, AB T3C 0W4

    Hours:
    Monday to Friday: 10:00 am – 7:00 pm
    Saturday: 12:00 pm – 4:00 pm
    Sunday: closed