Greg Ichshenko

Calgary SEO expert and digital marketing specialist,
developing advertising strategies for businesses of all sizes

(403) 308-5949

greg@to-the-top.ca
1509 14 Ave SW, Calgary,
AB T3C 0W4

    Submit your request or question, and I will get back
    to you shortly

    What Should My SEO Company Guarantee Me?

    What should your SEO company guarantee you? The work, not a ranking. That means a written scope of what will be done each month, methods that follow Google’s Search Essentials, reports drawn from accounts you own, ownership of your content and data, and clear terms for leaving. What it cannot guarantee is a position in Google, and Google says so directly on its page about hiring an SEO: “No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google.” A provider who commits firmly to the first list and declines to promise the second is giving you the most reliable sign that it understands how search works.

    The Guarantee Most People Ask For vs What They Should Actually Want

    This guide is written by SEO Company To-The-TOP!, a Calgary practice working in search since 2007, for business owners who have been offered a guarantee or who want to know what to ask for before they sign. It covers why rankings cannot be promised, what can be, how ranking and traffic guarantees are usually constructed, and the clauses worth having in writing.

    Why no one can guarantee a ranking

    Google decides what appears in its organic results, and it states that it never accepts money to include or rank sites there. No agency, however experienced, controls the algorithm, the competitors who are improving their own pages at the same time, or the updates Google makes to its ranking systems through the year. Results also differ by location and by searcher, so a page that sits third for someone in Calgary can sit lower for someone in Vancouver searching the same words. A guarantee of a specific position is a promise about things the provider does not control.

    Google’s guidance is blunt about what that means for you. It says to “beware of SEOs that claim to guarantee rankings, allege a ‘special relationship’ with Google, or advertise a ‘priority submit’ to Google”, and, on audits, “If they guarantee you that their changes will give you first place in search results, find someone else.” Google does not prohibit the promise, and some providers still make it, but its own advice to site owners is to treat it as a warning sign.

    What an SEO company can and cannot promise

    The useful distinction is between outcomes, which depend on Google and your competitors, and commitments, which depend only on the provider. A good contract is built entirely from the second kind.

    Can be promised How you can check it Cannot be promised
    A defined monthly scope (pages, fixes, content, links) A monthly log with the URLs changed A specific position for any keyword
    Methods that follow Google Search Essentials A plain explanation of every tactic used First page within a set number of days
    Reporting on agreed keywords, traffic and enquiries Figures you can confirm in your own Search Console and GA4 A set number of visitors or leads
    You keep ownership of accounts, content and data Your business listed as Owner or Administrator That a ranking, once reached, will hold
    A stated notice period and exit process Written in the agreement before you sign Immunity from Google updates

    What a Real SEO Guarantee Looks Like

    Every item in the left column can be checked by you, without trusting the provider’s own dashboard. That is the test worth applying to any promise. Commitments also make sense only once someone has looked at your site, so expect them after a technical audit of your site rather than in a sales call. An audit, as Google puts it, “should be about giving you realistic estimates of improvement, and an estimate of the work involved”, which is a long way from a guarantee.

    How ranking and traffic guarantees are made to look safe

    A guarantee can be true on its face and still worth little, which is why it is worth reading carefully. The simplest way to make one easy to keep is to choose the keywords carefully. A provider might guarantee first page for long phrases almost nobody searches, or for your business name, which often ranks already. The guarantee is met, the report looks good, and none of it brings in a customer who did not already know you.

    The remedy is the second place to look. Some ranking guarantees promise a refund only after a long period, or promise only that the provider will keep working without charge until the target is reached. Check, too, where and how rankings are measured. A provider can choose a rank checker, a location and a device on which the result looks best, and a position that only appears from one suburb or in one tool is not something you can verify.

    An organic traffic guarantee has a similar weakness. Visits are easy to inflate with content that attracts readers from other countries or topics that have nothing to do with what you sell, so a traffic floor can be met while enquiries stay flat. If you are offered one, it should be tied to visits from your service area to the pages that sell your services, measured in your own analytics account.

    The riskier case is a provider that can only keep its guarantee by cutting corners, through link schemes, large numbers of low-value pages made mainly to manipulate rankings, or other tactics that break Google’s spam policies. Google warns that “if an SEO creates deceptive or misleading content on your behalf, your site could be removed entirely from Google’s index”, and adds that “ultimately, you are responsible for the actions of any companies you hire.” That is the real cost of a guarantee that cannot be met fairly, and it falls on the business, not the agency. The article on the other warning signs to watch for covers the tactics in more detail.

    The commitments to get in writing

    A sound SEO agreement describes the work closely enough that you could tell at the end of any month whether it was done. That means the deliverables by month (for example, the number of pages written or rewritten, the technical fixes in scope and how link building will be approached), the keywords and pages the work is aimed at, and what the report will contain and when it will arrive. A line such as “ongoing SEO work” is not a scope. Ask as well for a log of every change made to your site, since Google’s own list of questions for an SEO includes whether it will “share with me all the changes you make to my site”.

    The agreement should also state the methods in plain language. A provider that follows Google’s Search Essentials can explain every tactic it uses without hesitation, and Google’s advice is to “be careful if a company is secretive or won’t clearly explain what they intend to do.” If you are still comparing providers, the questions worth asking before you hire will help you test those answers before anything is signed.

    Account ownership and exit terms

    The most valuable thing an SEO company can guarantee is that everything built for you stays yours. Your search data, your analytics history and your Google Business Profile should belong to your business, with the provider added as a user you can remove. Google’s own access roles make this straightforward.

    Account Your business should hold The provider should get
    Google Search Console Owner (“full control over properties”) Full user, or Restricted user for view-only work; read access only during an audit, as Google advises
    Google Analytics 4 Administrator A role that matches the work, such as Editor or Analyst
    Google Business Profile Owner, ideally the primary owner Manager, which Google describes as “mostly the same access to the profile as owners” except adding or removing users or removing the profile
    Website and hosting The admin and hosting logins Its own user account
    Domain name Registered to your business No access needed for most SEO work

    The Exit Clause as a Trust Signal

    Exit terms belong in the same conversation. Ask for the notice period and any minimum term in writing, check whether the agreement renews automatically, and confirm that content written for your site remains yours if you leave. If there is a minimum term, ask what work depends on it and what it costs to leave early; a short, clearly stated notice period is a reasonable thing to ask for. For Canadian businesses, check too whether the quoted fee includes GST or HST (the rate depends on the province where the service is supplied; in Alberta it is the 5% GST), and whether invoices are in Canadian or US dollars.

    Reporting that shows the commitments are kept

    Monthly reporting is only a guarantee if it shows the right things. A useful report covers positions for the agreed keywords, organic clicks and impressions from Search Console, enquiries or other conversions from your analytics, and a list of the work completed against the work planned. The guide on how to read an SEO report explains what each of those figures means and which ones to look at first.

    Reporting That Means Something

    Conversion tracking should be agreed at the start, because traffic without enquiry data tells only half the story, and it is the only way to tell later whether your SEO company is working for the business rather than for the report. A report that only ever shows good months is also a warning, since rankings rise and fall and a provider who explains a drop clearly is more useful than one who hides it.

    Evidence of past work helps you judge a provider before you sign. To-The-TOP! reports positions to its clients every month and keeps a public portfolio of ranked keywords, so the keywords can be searched rather than taken on trust, allowing for differences by location and device. Whoever you hire, ask for examples you can search for yourself.

    Timelines and performance-based pricing

    A timeline cannot be guaranteed either, because it depends on your site’s starting point, your competitors and how much work is in scope. SEO takes months, and impressions, clicks, average position and enquiries do not always move at the same time, so agree in advance which of them you will review at each checkpoint. What a provider can commit to is a written estimate for your situation, with the checkpoints at which you will review progress together and the reasons if the plan changes.

    What About a Timeline Guarantee?

    Performance-based or pay-for-results pricing is a variation on the guarantee and needs the same scrutiny. It can work when the result is defined tightly, such as enquiries from organic search measured in your own analytics, but a payment tied to rankings or raw sessions rewards the provider for chasing easy keywords and volume rather than customers. If you accept one, define the measure, the source of the data and the location in the contract.

    If you need enquiries while the organic work builds, a Google Ads campaign can fill the gap, since paid ads can appear as soon as a campaign is approved. It is a separate service with its own costs, so ask for the management fee and the ad spend as two separate numbers, and it does not change how Google ranks your organic pages.

    If a guarantee turns out to be misleading

    Google’s page on hiring an SEO points people who feel deceived to the Federal Trade Commission in the United States and to econsumer.gov for companies in other countries. In Canada, the relevant law is the Competition Act, which the Competition Bureau summarises plainly: “it is against the law to advertise or market something in a way that is false or misleading.” Keep the original offer, the contract and the reports, because the wording of the guarantee is what any complaint will turn on. A provider that promised only what it controlled will rarely give you a reason to look this up.

    If you would like a second opinion on an SEO proposal or a guarantee you have been offered, or on what your current provider is delivering, call To-The-TOP! at (403) 308-5949.

    Contact Calgary SEO Company To-The-TOP!

    Questions about anything in this article, or about your own rankings? Talk to a Calgary SEO specialist directly.

    Phone: (403) 308-5949
    Address: 1509 14 Ave SW, Calgary, AB T3C 0W4

    Hours:
    Monday to Friday: 10:00 am – 7:00 pm
    Saturday: 12:00 pm – 4:00 pm
    Sunday: closed