Greg Ichshenko

Calgary SEO expert and digital marketing specialist,
developing advertising strategies for businesses of all sizes

(403) 308-5949

greg@to-the-top.ca
1509 14 Ave SW, Calgary,
AB T3C 0W4

    Submit your request or question, and I will get back
    to you shortly

    How Much Keyword Difficulty Is Good for SEO?

    Illustration of a man climbing a set of rising bars toward the tallest one, highlighted in orange

    As a rule of thumb, for most new or small websites, a good keyword difficulty is under 30 on the usual 0 to 100 scale, and the safest wins sit under about 15. Once a site has some history, a few earned links and keywords already ranking, scores between 30 and roughly 50 become realistic, while anything above 50 usually needs links built to the page and many months of work. Those ranges line up with what the tool makers publish themselves: Semrush calls 0 to 14 “very easy” and 15 to 29 “easy”, and Moz says keywords get significantly tougher at a score of around 40. The more useful answer, though, is that a good score is one below what your own site already ranks for, and the rest of this article shows how to find that number.

    A good keyword difficulty depends on the site chasing it

    A difficulty score describes the pages that already rank, not the site that wants to join them. That is why the same score can be an easy target for one business and out of reach for another. Moz makes the point plainly in its help pages: a powerful site with many links may rank for keywords in the 60s and 70s, while a brand-new site with few positive signals may find even keywords in the 20s or 30s “pretty tough”.

    As a working rule of thumb, the ranges look like this. A new site, or one with almost no links from other websites, should aim under 30 and favour the lower half of that range. A site with steady content, some links and a set of keywords already on page one can work in the 30 to 50 band. Scores above 50 belong to sites with strong link profiles, or to pages the business is prepared to support with outreach and patience, because SEO results on competitive terms take months rather than weeks.

    The better test is a personal one, and Ahrefs suggests it: look up the difficulty scores of the keywords your site already ranks for, and that list gives you a benchmark drawn from evidence, which Ahrefs stresses is no substitute for studying the results themselves. As an illustrative example, picture a Calgary landscaping site that ranks on page one for a dozen phrases, all scored between 8 and 24 in the tool it uses. A new target at 20 is a reasonable bet for that site, a target at 35 is a stretch that needs a stronger page and probably a few links, and a target at 60 is a long project rather than a next step.

    Illustration of a man holding up a sheet with a large letter A, like a grade

    What a keyword difficulty score measures

    Every major tool uses a 0 to 100 scale, but each one calculates it from different data, and none of them is Google. Google does not publish a keyword difficulty score for organic search. The “Competition” column in Google’s own Keyword Planner is often mistaken for one, yet Google Ads Help defines it as “the number of advertisers that showed on each keyword relative to all keywords across Google”, so it tells you about the ad auction rather than the organic results.

    Tool What its score is based on (per its own documentation) What it says about the numbers
    Semrush (KD%) The median number of referring domains, the dofollow and nofollow ratio and the authority score of the ranking domains, plus features of the results page 0-14 very easy, 15-29 easy, 30-49 possible, 50-69 difficult, 70-84 hard, 85-100 very hard
    Ahrefs (KD) How many websites link to each of the top 10 ranking pages KD 0-5: the top pages barely have backlinks; about 50: a couple of hundred; 90 and up: thousands
    Moz (Difficulty) The Page Authority and Domain Authority of the first-page results, weighted toward the higher positions Keywords get significantly tougher at around 40; there is “no single score that’s always good or always bad”

    Read together, the three definitions show what difficulty mostly measures: the link strength of the pages already on page one. It does not measure whether those pages answer the search well, whether they are out of date, or whether your site is a better fit for the searcher. A score is a fast way to sort a long list, and it is a poor way to make the final decision about a single keyword. For the mechanics of finding the score in each tool, the separate guide on how to check a keyword’s difficulty walks through it.

    Illustration of a man pinning a KW card on a board of SEO metric cards such as rank, volume, links, authority and tools

    Why the same keyword scores differently in every tool

    Ahrefs states on its own blog that the scores for the same keyword “will vary quite substantially” between tools, which follows from the table above. Each vendor crawls a different slice of the web, counts links differently and weights the top results differently, so a 40 in one tool and a 40 in another are not the same measurement. Comparing scores across tools tells you very little.

    Scores also move within a single tool for phrases that mean nearly the same thing. In a Semrush keyword export from 28 March 2026, the question this article answers, “how much keyword difficulty is good for SEO”, is scored 23, while “what is a good keyword difficulty” is scored 37. A searcher would treat those as the same question, yet a site using a strict cut-off of 30 would accept one and reject the other. That is a good reason to look at the cluster of phrases around a topic rather than a single row in a spreadsheet.

    The practical rule is to pick one tool, stay with it, and compare its scores with your own results over several months. After a while the number starts to mean something for your site, because you know which scores turned into rankings and which did not, and switching tools resets that experience.

    Illustration of a man beside a balance scale weighing a coin against weights

    When a high score is worth it and a low one is not

    The biggest gap in any difficulty score, for a Calgary business, is location. Semrush, Ahrefs and Moz all describe their scores in terms of the top 10 organic results, not the map pack, while Google says it uses “your location and settings” to decide what is most relevant to each searcher. A search like “furnace repair Calgary” often shows a map pack above the organic results, and Google’s local ranking help page says those results are “mainly based on relevance, distance, and popularity”, a mix that a difficulty score built on the organic top 10 was never designed to measure, even though Google says links to a business play some part. For a phrase that brings up a map pack, local visibility has to be judged separately from the organic score, and the only way to see what a Calgary searcher gets is to search it from Calgary.

    A high score can also hide a weak results page. If the top results are old forum threads, thin directory listings or pages that answer a different question, a well-built page can compete even when the number looks discouraging, because the links behind those pages are not doing the work of answering the search. The reverse also happens, because a low score attached to a page one full of strong, specific answers is not as easy as it looks.

    Low scores have their own traps. A low score says nothing about demand, so check the search volume before getting excited, and remember that Canadian volumes are usually far smaller than the American figures many tools show by default. A low-difficulty keyword that does not match what the business sells brings visitors who leave, and a phrase built around a competitor’s brand name may score low while being almost impossible to win, since Google has good reason to show the brand’s own site first.

    Illustration of a man pointing to a highlighted pin on a city map

    Where difficulty belongs in a Calgary keyword plan

    Difficulty works best as the last filter rather than the first. The order that holds up in practice starts with intent, because a keyword is only worth having if the people searching it want what the business offers. Search volume comes next, read for Canada or for Calgary where the tool allows it. Difficulty then sorts what remains, and the results page itself makes the final call. The broader process is covered in the guide to how to choose keywords.

    In practice that means four questions for each candidate phrase. Does the searcher want what the business sells, and would the page that answers it be one the business wants to rank? Do enough people in the market search it, counting close variants together? Is the score at or below the site’s own ceiling, or close enough that a strong page and a few links could bridge the gap? And when you search it from Calgary, what do the top results look like, and could your page be clearly better for that searcher? A keyword that passes all four is a good target whatever its exact score. A keyword that fails the first two is a poor one even at a difficulty of 5.

    Small Calgary service businesses usually do best with a mix. Most of the list should sit at or under the site’s ceiling, so that some pages have a realistic chance of earning impressions and clicks, and Search Console can show what is working. A few higher-difficulty keywords that matter to revenue can be chosen deliberately and supported over a longer period. This is the balance that professional keyword research is meant to strike, because the right list depends on the site’s current strength as much as on the market.

    Illustration of a man dropping a coin into a box labelled AD

    Some of the most valuable phrases in a market will be too difficult for a young site for a long time, and difficulty scores do not tell you what to do about that. One answer is to bid on those searches with Google Ads while the organic pages build strength, then compare the paid search terms report with Search Console to see which phrases are worth the long organic effort. Paid clicks cost money every month, so this suits keywords that lead to enquiries rather than research questions.

    If you would like a second opinion on which keywords your site can realistically win, SEO Company To-The-TOP! is a Calgary SEO and Google Ads practice founded in 2007, and the person who reviews your keyword list is the person who does the work. Call (403) 308-5949.

    Contact Calgary SEO Company To-The-TOP!

    Questions about anything in this article, or about your own rankings? Talk to a Calgary SEO specialist directly.

    Phone: (403) 308-5949
    Address: 1509 14 Ave SW, Calgary, AB T3C 0W4

    Hours:
    Monday to Friday: 10:00 am – 7:00 pm
    Saturday: 12:00 pm – 4:00 pm
    Sunday: closed