Greg Ichshenko

Calgary SEO expert and digital marketing specialist,
developing advertising strategies for businesses of all sizes

(403) 308-5949

greg@to-the-top.ca
1509 14 Ave SW, Calgary,
AB T3C 0W4

    Submit your request or question, and I will get back
    to you shortly

    How to Do Competitor Analysis in SEO

    SEO competitor analysis is the work of studying the pages that outrank you for the searches you want, so you can see why Google prefers them and decide what to change on your own site. To do it, find the sites that actually rank for your target searches, read the results page to see what format Google rewards, compare keywords, content, backlinks and technical health, check the map pack separately if you serve a local area, and then turn the gaps into a short list of work in order of impact. The steps below follow that order, because each one narrows what the next one has to look at, and they lean on free data from Google before any paid tool.


    Illustration of a smiling man in a white shirt holding an orange box, with a speech bubble above him, on a dark blue background

    Step 1: Find your search competitors, which may differ from your business rivals

    Your SEO competitors are whoever ranks for the searches you want, and that list often looks different from the companies you lose quotes to. The difference between search competitors and business competitors matters because a directory, a national publisher or a supplier’s blog can hold the positions you need without ever selling the same service. Start by writing down the five to ten searches that would bring you paying customers, search each one, and record every domain on page one.

    Search from the place your customers search from, or use a rank checker set to that city, because results for many service searches change with location. A Calgary furnace company searching from its own office will see a different page than a customer in Airdrie or Okotoks, and neither will match a national ranking report. Paid tools such as Semrush and Ahrefs can add a “competing domains” or “organic competitors” list based on keyword overlap, which is useful on larger sites, although it is still worth checking that list against what real searches show.

    Illustration of a man in a tie holding up an orange card that reads "Your SEO competitors", standing beside a box of notes about searching for keywords in Google

    Then trim the list. Keep the domains that rank for several of your searches and look like sites you could realistically match, and set aside very large brands and reference sites that rank on sheer size. A small Calgary business does not need to study a national publisher’s link profile, although it should still notice when one holds a spot it wants, because that tells you the page type Google is choosing for that search.

    Step 2: Read the results page before you open a tool

    Before you compare anyone’s numbers, look at what Google shows for each search, because the results page tells you what kind of answer it rewards. Note whether page one is made of service pages, how-to guides, comparison articles, local map results, videos or forum threads, and whether ads sit above it all. If every result for “furnace repair Calgary” is a service page with a phone number and a map pack sits on top, a blog post will not win that search however well it is written, and the real competition is for the map and the service page.

    This step also stops a common waste of effort. Plenty of competitor analyses end with a plan to write longer articles, when the search in question rewards a short local service page or a product listing. Matching the format and the intent first means the rest of the comparison is between like and like.

    Step 3: Compare keywords and find the gaps

    A keyword gap is a search your competitors rank for and you do not. Keyword gap reports in Semrush, Ahrefs and similar tools put your domain beside a handful of competitors and list the terms each one ranks for, so you can filter for the ones where they appear and you are missing. Sort the list by relevance to what you sell before you sort by volume, because a modest search that matches a service you offer is worth more than a large one you could never convert.

    Illustration of a man in an orange tie holding two pages, one labelled "Step 2" and one labelled "keyword gap analysis"

    Look for patterns rather than single terms. If three competitors all rank for questions about a topic you never cover, that is a missing page or section, and one well-built page often covers a whole group of related searches. If you already run Google Ads, add your search terms report to the picture: searches that bring paid conversions show you which organic gaps are worth closing first, since those searches already lead to calls, forms or sales you track as conversions.

    Free options exist if you do not pay for a tool. Your own Google Search Console Performance report shows the queries you already get impressions for and your average position on each. That is first-party data from Google, although some rare queries are hidden for privacy, and it covers only sites you have verified, so it shows nothing about anyone else. Comparing that list with what you see when you search by hand is a slower but workable keyword gap analysis for a small site.

    Step 4: Study the pages that outrank you, then do better than them

    Open the two or three pages that rank above you for your most important searches and read them as a customer would. Note what they answer in the first screen, which subtopics they cover that you do not, whether they show prices, examples, photos of real work or step-by-step instructions, and how recently they were updated. That reading tells you more than any content score, because it shows you what the searcher gets from each result.

    Google’s own guidance sets the limit on how far to take this. Its helpful content questions ask whether a page provides “substantial value when compared to other pages in search results”, and whether content that draws on other sources avoids “simply copying or rewriting those sources” and instead adds “substantial additional value and originality”. In practice that means the competitor’s page tells you what the minimum is, and your page has to add something theirs lacks, such as your own process, local detail, clearer pricing guidance or better examples.

    Illustration of a man breaking through a finish-line ribbon ahead of two other runners

    The same review works at the topic level. A content gap analysis looks for whole subjects your competitors cover and you do not, which is often how a small site with a handful of service pages finds the guides and supporting pages it needs.

    Step 5: Look at their backlinks with the right expectations

    Google’s guide to its ranking systems still lists link analysis systems and PageRank among them, and links from other sites feed the prominence of a local business too, so a backlink gap analysis is part of any serious comparison. Tools such as Ahrefs’ Link Intersect and Semrush’s backlink gap report list sites that link to your competitors but not to you. The useful entries are usually local ones: industry associations, suppliers, chambers of commerce, event sponsors, local news and community sites that link to businesses like yours and might link to you for the same reason.

    Be careful with the scores these tools attach. Domain Authority, Domain Rating and similar numbers are each vendor’s own estimate of link strength, and Moz states plainly that Domain Authority “is not a Google ranking factor and has no effect on the SERPs”. They are fine for comparing sites roughly, but a rule such as “only chase links above 40” filters out the local links that often matter most to a Calgary business. Also keep within Google’s spam policies, which list “buying or selling links for ranking purposes” as link spam, so a competitor’s paid links are something to note, not something to copy.

    Step 6: Compare technical health and how the pages appear in search

    Check whether the competing pages load quickly, work well on a phone and show clean titles and descriptions in the results. Google’s page experience documentation says that “Core Web Vitals are used by our ranking systems”, and in the same page it says good results in reports or third-party tools do not guarantee top rankings, so treat speed as a floor to clear rather than a way to leapfrog a better page. PageSpeed Insights will show you field data for a competitor’s URL when Google has enough of it, which makes a fair side-by-side comparison with your own page.

    Structured data deserves a fresh look, because a lot of competitor-analysis advice is out of date here. Google no longer shows How-to rich results, and its documentation changelog records that FAQ rich results stopped appearing from 7 May 2026, so copying a competitor’s FAQ or HowTo markup will not earn you an extra feature on the results page. Markup that still has a visible use, such as LocalBusiness details and breadcrumbs (now shown on desktop results only), is worth comparing, though review stars are not available for reviews a business hosts about itself. Title tags, heading structure and how well each site links its own related pages together are worth comparing too.

    Step 7: For local searches, run a second analysis on the map pack

    If you serve customers in a set area, the map pack is often the most valuable part of the results page, and its competitors are frequently different businesses from the ones in the organic results. Google’s Business Profile help says local results are “mainly based on relevance, distance, and popularity”, and that prominence draws on information such as how many websites link to a business and how many reviews it has. Distance is outside your control, so compare the parts you can change.

    For each business that outranks you in the map pack, note its primary category, the services it lists, its review count and recent review activity, whether it replies to reviews, its photos and whether its website has a page for the service and the area. For a Calgary business, check the map from more than one part of the city, because a competitor sitting near the searcher can outrank a stronger profile across town. That one observation often explains a ranking gap that no website change would close.

    Use the competitor data Google gives you for free

    If you run Google Ads, the auction insights report is the most direct competitor data available, because it comes from Google’s own auctions rather than a tool’s estimate. For Search campaigns it gives six statistics (impression share, overlap rate, outranking share, position above rate, top of page rate and absolute top of the page rate), and it shows no insights when your impression share is under 10%. It tells you who competes for the same paid searches you do and how often they appear above you, and some of those advertisers may also be organic rivals, which you can check in the unpaid results. In a managed Google Ads account it is usually part of regular reporting.

    The Ads Transparency Center is free for anyone, advertiser or not. Google says ads served on its platforms, including Search and YouTube, can be found there, and you can search for an advertiser and see its ads, which shows you the offers and messages competitors pay to promote. You can learn more about how to check what competitors are running in Google Ads, and the wording that keeps appearing in their ads is often the wording your organic titles and service pages should answer too.

    What competitor numbers in SEO tools really mean

    Most of what a tool shows you about another site is an estimate, which is fine as long as you read it that way. The table sets out the common metrics and how much weight each can carry.

    Metric Where it comes from Good for Its limit
    Your queries, clicks and positions Google Search Console First-party data on your own Google search performance Shows only sites you have verified, nothing about competitors
    Competitor organic traffic Modelled by the tool vendor from rankings and estimated volumes Comparing sites roughly and spotting trends Can be far from real visits, especially for small local sites
    Domain Authority, Domain Rating and similar scores Each vendor’s own link model A rough comparison of link strength Not used by Google; Moz says DA is not a ranking factor
    Keyword volumes Tool estimates or Google Keyword Planner ranges Choosing between similar terms Small local terms often show low or no volume yet still bring customers
    Auction insights Google Ads auctions Who competes in your paid searches and how often they appear above you Only for your own campaigns; no data under 10% impression share

    Turn the analysis into a plan

    An analysis only pays off when it changes what you work on next. Put every finding in one list, give each a rough impact and effort rating, and start with the items that are high impact and low effort, such as a missing service page for a search that already converts in Google Ads, or a Business Profile category that every map competitor uses and you do not, and that accurately describes your business. The table below is an illustrative example for an invented Calgary renovation company, not real client data.

    Finding Impact Effort Order
    No page for basement development, which three map-pack competitors have High Medium 1
    Business Profile missing the services competitors list High Low 2
    Competitors’ guides answer cost and permit questions this site never covers Medium Medium 3
    Local association and supplier sites link to two competitors but not this one Medium High 4
    Competitor pages load faster on mobile Low to medium Medium 5

    Illustration of a man laying the last plank of a bridge across a gap towards a flag that reads "Results"

    There is no fixed schedule for repeating the work. Revisit it when your rankings or map position change noticeably, when a new competitor appears on page one for a search you care about, before you plan a new batch of content, and after a confirmed Google core update. Some changes show up within weeks and others take several months, so judge the plan on the trend over a season rather than week to week.

    If you would rather have someone else run this for your market, SEO Company To-The-TOP! is a Calgary SEO and Google Ads company founded in 2007, with one expert doing the work and monthly position reporting. A competitor comparison fits naturally inside an SEO audit of your site, and you can call (403) 308-5949 to talk through which searches matter most for your business.

    Contact Calgary SEO Company To-The-TOP!

    Questions about anything in this article, or about your own rankings? Talk to a Calgary SEO specialist directly.

    Phone: (403) 308-5949
    Address: 1509 14 Ave SW, Calgary, AB T3C 0W4

    Hours:
    Monday to Friday: 10:00 am – 7:00 pm
    Saturday: 12:00 pm – 4:00 pm
    Sunday: closed