Greg Ichshenko

Calgary SEO expert and digital marketing specialist,
developing advertising strategies for businesses of all sizes

(403) 308-5949

greg@to-the-top.ca
1509 14 Ave SW, Calgary,
AB T3C 0W4

    Submit your request or question, and I will get back
    to you shortly

    How to Set Performance Expectations With an SEO Consultant

    To set performance expectations with an SEO consultant, put five things in writing before any work starts: where the site stands today, the business result that counts as success, the order in which the numbers should move over the coming months, how often and in what form results will be reported, and what kind of drop would count as a real problem. Google’s own advice for hiring an SEO tells you to ask what results the person expects, in what timeframe, and how they measure success. A consultant who answers those questions in writing, without promising a position nobody can control, has given you something you can hold the work against.


    A man reading a bookmarked book, representing the homework done before an SEO engagement starts

    Start with a written baseline

    Expectations only mean something when there is a starting point to compare against, so the first job is recording where the site stands before anything changes. The most useful baseline comes from Google Search Console, because it is Google’s own record of how your site appears in search. Its Performance report shows clicks, impressions, click-through rate and average position, and its default view covers the past three months, which makes it a natural “before” snapshot. Save that view with the date on it, along with the pages and queries that already bring in traffic.

    Add the numbers your business actually lives on. If your site runs Google Analytics 4, note how many leads, calls or sales it recorded as key events over the same period, and if most enquiries come by phone, write down a rough monthly call count from your own records. A baseline that stops at rankings will make the later reports look like progress on paper even when the phone is no busier than before.

    Two details are worth knowing before you read any ranking figure. Search Console’s average position is the position of the topmost result from your site, averaged across searches, so it can move when the mix of queries changes even if no single ranking did. And Google’s help page notes that search results depend on the time, place, device and recent history of the person searching. Searching your own business name from your office in Calgary is not a ranking report, and a consultant who checks positions from a fixed location gives you a steadier comparison than your own phone does.

    If the consultant needs access to start, Google’s hiring guidance says to grant read access to Search Console during an audit and not write access. That keeps the baseline in your hands, which matters later if you ever change providers.

    A man at a laptop watching a paper plane fly off, representing the moment the work is handed over

    Agree on what success means in business terms

    Rankings and traffic are signals, but they are not the result you are paying for. Before work starts, agree on the business outcome the SEO is meant to change, and describe it specifically enough that both sides could check it a year from now. For a trades company that might be booked estimates from the website, for a clinic it might be new-patient enquiries, and for an online store it is orders and revenue from organic search.

    Once the outcome is clear, the target keywords follow from it. Terms chosen because they have large search volumes can pull in visitors who were never going to buy, which inflates traffic without touching revenue, while narrower terms with buying intent may look small and still produce the work you want. Ask the consultant to show which pages and which searches are expected to drive the agreed outcome, so that a later report can connect the two.

    It also helps to agree on what is out of scope. If the contact form breaks on mobile or the site needs development work to load faster, that work may sit outside the agreed SEO scope, and the expectations sheet should say who is responsible for each piece.

    A man planting a flag on a mountain summit, representing an agreed definition of success

    Set the timeline as stages, not dates

    SEO is judged over months, and no consultant can tell you the exact week a page will reach a given position. Separately, Google’s own guidance on traffic changes says that after you change a site, some changes can take effect in a few days while others could take several months, and that there is no guarantee a change will have a noticeable effect at all. A more useful expectation than a deadline is the order in which the numbers should move, which is also how the article on how long SEO usually takes, stage by stage frames it.

    Stage What progress looks like What to watch
    Groundwork Audit, technical fixes, page improvements and a content plan, done and documented A written list of changes with dates
    Early signals Changed pages recrawled; if visibility improves, impressions usually move for target queries before clicks do Impressions and average position for the target pages in Search Console
    Traffic Clicks rise on the pages tied to the target keywords Clicks to those pages, compared with the same period a year earlier where seasonality matters
    Business result If the traffic is the right traffic, leads, calls or sales from organic search should follow The agreed outcome, measured the same way as the baseline

    Ask the consultant to put rough month ranges against each stage for your site and your market, and to say what would make them longer. A competitive Calgary term held by established local companies will usually take longer than a niche service few others have written about, and a site with technical problems has to clear them before the content can do much.

    If the business needs leads during the months this takes, that is a separate decision rather than something SEO can be pushed to deliver early. Google states that advertising with Google has no effect on a site’s presence in its organic results, so paid search buys visibility now but does not speed up the organic side. Some businesses run both for that reason, with the budgets and the results reported separately.

    A man watering a row of growing bar-chart plants, representing results that build in stages

    Decide in advance what counts as a real drop

    Rankings move all the time, and much of that movement means nothing. Google’s guide to traffic drops says positions “aren’t static or fixed in place”, and that small fluctuations can happen at any time and can reverse without you doing anything. Its own example of a small drop is a page moving from position 2 to 4, while a large drop is falling out of the top 10 to around position 29 across a wide range of terms. Agreeing on that distinction before the first bad week saves a lot of anxious phone calls.

    A sensible agreement covers three checks. First, look at the Google Search Status Dashboard, which lists confirmed ranking updates; as of November 2026, its entries for this year show core updates in March and May and spam updates in March, June, August and September, and a drop that lines up with one of those dates may have a cause outside the consultant’s work, although the affected pages and any recent site changes still need checking. Second, compare the period with the same months a year earlier, because seasonal demand can lower traffic with no change in rankings at all, and Google Trends can show interest down to the city level. Third, check whether the drop affects the whole site, a group of pages or one important page, since each points to a different cause.

    Google’s guidance is also to wait a few weeks after a change before analyzing the results again in Search Console. Write that into the agreement as a rule for both sides: no radical changes because of one bad week, and a proper review, in writing, if the agreed metrics fall for a sustained period. The exception is anything broken, such as the site going down, pages accidentally set to noindex or tracking that stops recording, which should be checked the same day.

    A man holding a stopwatch beside a large gauge, representing patience with normal ranking movement

    What the monthly report should show

    A monthly report is where expectations either hold or fall apart, so agree on its contents at the start. Search Console itself offers weekly and monthly views to smooth out daily swings, which is a good reason to judge progress monthly rather than by checking rankings every morning.

    Report item What it tells you What it does not tell you
    Positions for the agreed keywords Whether the target pages are gaining visibility Whether anyone clicked or bought
    Impressions and clicks for the target pages Whether visibility is turning into visits Whether the visits were the right people
    The agreed business outcome Whether enquiries or sales from organic search are moving in the agreed direction Which single change caused it
    Work completed and planned What the fee bought this month Whether it was the right work, unless it is tied to the numbers above

    The report should cover the same keywords and pages agreed at the start, not a longer list padded with easy terms, and it should explain movement in plain language rather than leaving you to interpret a chart. If you want to check a report yourself, the guide on how to read an SEO report walks through each section.

    A man reeling in a tag marked "context", representing reports that explain the numbers

    Questions to settle before you sign

    Most expectation problems start with something nobody asked. Google’s hiring page lists several questions worth asking, including what results the SEO expects and in what timeframe, how they measure success, whether they follow Google Search Essentials, what experience they have in your industry and city, and whether they will share every change they make with the reasoning behind it. The answers to the first two belong in your written expectations, and there is a longer list of questions worth asking before you sign if you are still choosing.

    The same page is direct about the warning signs. It says no one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google, and to beware of anyone who claims to guarantee rankings, claims a “special relationship” with Google or offers a “priority submit”. It also reminds site owners that they are responsible for the actions of any company they hire, which is a good reason to expect the consultant to explain what they are changing and why. A vague answer about method is the point where expectations stop being checkable.

    An example expectations sheet

    The following is an illustrative example, not a client case. Picture a Calgary heating and cooling company that wants more furnace and air-conditioning service calls from its website. Before work starts, the owner and the consultant agree on a single page covering these points:

    1. Baseline: Search Console clicks, impressions and average position for the last three months, the service pages that already get traffic, and the monthly count of website form leads and calls tracked as GA4 key events, all dated.
    2. Success: more booked service calls from organic search, measured the same way as the baseline.
    3. Target pages and searches: the furnace repair, furnace installation and air-conditioning pages, matched to the Calgary searches each should rank for.
    4. Stages: groundwork first, then impressions, then clicks, then leads, with the consultant’s rough month ranges for each and the reasons they could run longer.
    5. Seasonality: a Google Trends check for Alberta, so that a quieter month for furnace searches is not mistaken for a ranking problem.
    6. Reporting: a monthly report with the four items in the table above.
    7. Review rule: no radical changes over one bad week; a written review if leads and target-page clicks both fall over a sustained period that isn’t explained by a confirmed Google update or the season.

    None of those lines promises a ranking, yet every one of them can be checked later, which is what makes it an expectation rather than a hope.

    A handshake beside an open door, representing an agreement both sides can hold each other to

    How To-The-TOP! approaches it

    SEO Company To-The-TOP! has worked in Calgary since 2007, and the person who sets the expectations is the person who does the work and writes the report, with no junior handoff in between. Clients get monthly position reporting, the work is White Hat only, and the site publishes a public portfolio of ranked keywords.

    With any consultant, To-The-TOP! included, ask to see the baseline, the success measure and the reporting format in writing before you agree to start. SEO Company To-The-TOP! is a solo practice, so the person who prices the work is the person who does it. To ask what your project would cost, call (403) 308-5949.

    Contact Calgary SEO Company To-The-TOP!

    Questions about anything in this article, or about your own rankings? Talk to a Calgary SEO specialist directly.

    Phone: (403) 308-5949
    Address: 1509 14 Ave SW, Calgary, AB T3C 0W4

    Hours:
    Monday to Friday: 10:00 am – 7:00 pm
    Saturday: 12:00 pm – 4:00 pm
    Sunday: closed