Greg Ichshenko

Calgary SEO expert and digital marketing specialist,
developing advertising strategies for businesses of all sizes

(403) 308-5949

greg@to-the-top.ca
1509 14 Ave SW, Calgary,
AB T3C 0W4

    Submit your request or question, and I will get back
    to you shortly

    Is Directory Submission Good for SEO?

    Mostly no. Submitting a website to general web directories is not a ranking tactic that works any more, and Google’s own spam policies list “low-quality directory or bookmark site links” as an example of link spam. A short list of directory listings is still worth having for a local business, though: Google Business Profile, the other main map and listing platforms, and a few trade, association and local directories that real customers use. Those help because they put accurate business information in front of people and can send enquiries, not because their links push a website up the rankings. The rest of this guide explains which listings to make, how to judge any directory that asks for your money, and what to do about directory links bought years ago.

    A man drawing a route between waypoints on a large map

    Why directory submission once worked, and what changed

    In the early years of Google, links behaved much like votes, and a directory listing was an easy vote to collect. Hand-edited directories reviewed every submission, so a listing really did say something about a business. That success attracted thousands of copies that accepted any site for a fee, and “submit to 500 directories” packages became a staple of low-cost SEO offers. The links were easy to get precisely because nobody was checking them, which is the opposite of what a link was supposed to signal.

    A man planting an orange flag on a mountain summit

    Google’s response came in stages. In April 2012 it launched an algorithm change aimed at webspam, including link schemes, which its announcement said would noticeably affect about 3.1% of English queries; that update became known as Penguin. In September 2016 Google made Penguin part of its core algorithm and said it “now devalues spam by adjusting ranking based on spam signals, rather than affecting ranking of the whole site.” In December 2022 it announced that SpamBrain, its AI-based spam-prevention system, could now detect sites buying links and sites used to pass outgoing links, and that the update would “neutralize the impact of unnatural links.” Put together, these mean that bulk directory links today are most likely to be worth nothing, rather than a reliable route to a penalty, although manual actions for unnatural links still exist.

    What Google’s spam policies say about directory links

    Google defines link spam as creating links “primarily for the purpose of manipulating search rankings.” Its list of examples includes buying or selling links for ranking purposes, excessive link exchanges, using automated programs or services to create links, and, by name, low-quality directory or bookmark site links. A typical bulk submission service ticks several of those boxes at once: the links are bought for ranking purposes, they are usually created automatically, and the directories involved are mostly the low-quality kind.

    A man joining two blocks with an orange chain link

    The same policy also explains why paying for a listing is not automatically a problem. Google says buying and selling links is a normal part of advertising and sponsorship on the web, and that such links do not break its policies as long as they carry a rel=”nofollow” or rel=”sponsored” attribute. Its guidance on qualifying outbound links asks sites to mark paid placements with the sponsored value. So a reputable paid directory that marks its listing links as sponsored is behaving correctly, and the fair way to judge it is as advertising: does it put your business in front of people who hire, and is that worth the fee? A directory that sells “dofollow” links as the main benefit is selling the thing the policy prohibits.

    Directory listings that still earn their place

    The most important directory for a business that meets customers in person, at its premises or theirs, is Google Business Profile, because it is the listing Google uses for the map results. Google’s help page on local ranking says local results are “mainly based on relevance, distance, and popularity”, and its description of prominence says it is “also based on info like how many websites link to your business and how many reviews you have.” That is about as close as Google comes to endorsing listings elsewhere on the web, and it points to quality and reviews rather than raw counts. There is more on what Google itself says about local rankings in a separate guide.

    A man pointing at a small storefront with an orange map pin above it

    Beyond that, a Calgary or other Canadian business will get most of the remaining value from a small set of listings, each doing a different job:

    Listing type Canadian or Calgary examples What it actually does Worth it?
    Google’s own business listing Google Business Profile Appears in Google Maps and the local pack; feeds location assets in Google Ads Essential
    Other map and app platforms Bing Places, Apple Business (Apple Maps), Yelp.ca Visibility for people who search in Bing, Apple Maps or Yelp instead of Google Yes, set up once and keep accurate
    Canadian general directories YellowPages.ca, Canada411 Possible referral traffic and another accurate copy of your details; little link value Usually, if free or low-cost
    Local membership directories Calgary Chamber member directory, BBB Alberta and East Kootenay Trust and referral from people checking a business before they hire If you are a member for other reasons
    Trade associations and regulators Your industry association or provincial licensing body’s public register Highly relevant listing that buyers in your field use Yes, where one exists
    Bulk “submit your URL” directories “350+ directory submission sites” lists Nothing useful; low-quality links Google names as link spam No

    A man turning a large dial on a gauge toward the high end

    You will often read that matching name, address and phone details across directories is a local ranking factor. Google does not document it as one, so treat it as practitioner reasoning rather than fact. The practical case for consistency is strong anyway: customers who find an old phone number or a former address on a directory may call the wrong line or drive to the wrong place, and a mismatch makes it harder for any system, Google’s included, to be sure two listings describe the same business. Keeping citations and consistent NAP data tidy is maintenance worth doing for that reason alone.

    How to tell a useful directory from a link scheme

    There is no correct number of directories. A plumber and a family lawyer will need different lists, and a business with five good listings is better placed than one with five hundred bad ones. Before submitting anywhere, run each directory through five questions:

    1. Would you want this listing if Google did not exist? Look up a service and a neighbourhood you know on the directory itself; if the categories are full of real local businesses and the listings show reviews or recent activity, people probably use it.
    2. Does anyone check submissions? A membership requirement, a licence check or an editor who sometimes rejects listings is a good sign. Instant approval for any site is not.
    3. Does it ask for a link back? A required reciprocal link is the “link to me and I’ll link to you” pattern Google’s policy lists under link exchanges, and a directory that demands one is telling you what it is for.
    4. Is it relevant to your market? A Calgary contractor gains nothing from a directory of overseas manufacturers or a listing in a language its customers do not read, and bulk packages are full of exactly those.
    5. If it charges, what are you paying for? Paying for exposure to buyers is advertising and can be fine. Paying for “dofollow” links or a promised ranking boost is not.

    A man crossing out a warning sign with an orange marker

    When a directory passes, make the listing complete: the exact legal or trading name you use on your own site, the same address format and phone number, the right category, a real description and your hours. The category matters more than most people expect, because on many directories it largely decides which searches the listing can appear for.

    What to do about old directory links

    Many businesses that have been online for a while carry links from a bulk submission someone bought years ago. The instinct is to clean them all up, but Google’s guidance points the other way. Its disavow help page says that “in most cases, Google can assess which links to trust without additional guidance, so most sites will not need to use this tool,” and it recommends disavowing only when a site has a considerable number of spammy, artificial or low-quality links and those links have caused, or are likely to cause, a manual action.

    A man in a blazer holding a report with a large letter A

    In practice that gives a simple order of work. Check the Manual actions report in Search Console first. If there is no manual action for unnatural links, most old directory links can be left alone, since Google’s systems are designed to ignore or neutralize them. If there is one, Google asks site owners to remove as many of the links as they can and to use the disavow tool for the ones they cannot, and the tool itself carries Google’s warning that incorrect use can harm a site’s performance in Search.

    Stop paying for any recurring submission service while you sort this out, and keep the handful of genuine listings that turn up in the backlink report, such as your Chamber or association profile. If you are not sure which is which, a full review of the site and its links is the better starting point than a blanket disavow file.

    Where directory work fits in a local SEO plan

    Directory listings are a supporting task, done carefully once and checked when something changes, such as a move, a new phone number or a rebrand. The work that moves local rankings sits elsewhere: a complete and active Google Business Profile, genuine reviews, a website with clear service and location pages, and links earned from local sources that would mention the business anyway, such as suppliers, sponsored community events and local media.

    A man moving an orange chess piece on a board

    Directory listings play no part in Google Ads, with one useful exception. Location assets, which can show your address, a map or the distance to your business in ads, take their data from Google Business Profile and Google Maps through a profile linked to the Ads account, so keeping the profile accurate keeps the address and phone details shown in ads correct as well. Other directory listings do not feed into ads in this way.

    If you have been offered a directory package, or you are not sure whether old directory links are a problem, it is worth getting a second opinion before spending more. SEO Company To-The-TOP! is a Calgary practice founded in 2007, where one expert handles the SEO and Google Ads work using White Hat methods only. Call (403) 308-5949 to talk through which listings your business needs and which ones it can skip.

    Contact Calgary SEO Company To-The-TOP!

    Questions about anything in this article, or about your own rankings? Talk to a Calgary SEO specialist directly.

    Phone: (403) 308-5949
    Address: 1509 14 Ave SW, Calgary, AB T3C 0W4

    Hours:
    Monday to Friday: 10:00 am – 7:00 pm
    Saturday: 12:00 pm – 4:00 pm
    Sunday: closed