How to Do a PPC Audit That Finds the Wasted Spend
A PPC audit is a structured review of a pay-per-click account, usually Google Ads, that checks whether the money is reaching the right searches and whether the results you see are real. To do one well, work in this order: confirm that conversion tracking counts real enquiries, check the campaign settings that quietly widen your reach, read the search terms report, review structure and match types, then ads and landing pages, then bidding and budgets, and finally compare yourself with competitors in auction insights. Order matters more than most checklists admit, because a finding made on broken tracking can send every later decision the wrong way.
This guide follows that order and names the Google Ads report or setting behind each check, so you can run it on your own account or use it to judge an audit someone else has handed you. It is written with a small or mid-sized service business in mind, where the account usually has a handful of campaigns and the goal is calls and form leads rather than online sales.
Before you start: access, a date range and the change history
You need at least read access to the Google Ads account and, ideally, to the Google Analytics property and the website’s tag setup, because a good share of problems live outside Google Ads. Pick a review window long enough to smooth out weekly swings; the last 90 days compared with the 90 days before is a common practitioner choice, and a seasonal business should also compare against the same months last year. Then open the change history, which Google keeps for the past two years and maps against impressions, clicks, conversions and cost. It shows who changed what and when, and it often explains a sudden drop or spike faster than any other report.
It also helps to be clear about what an audit is not. The optimization score at the top of the account is, in Google’s words, “an estimate of how well your Google Ads account is set to perform”, and it rises as you apply or dismiss Google’s recommendations. That makes it a useful list of suggestions to consider, but a high score does not prove the account is profitable, and a low one does not prove it is wasting money.
1. Start with conversion tracking
Every other check in the audit relies on the conversion numbers, so they come first. Go to Goals, then Summary, and look at the Status column for each conversion action; Google uses five overview statuses, and anything other than Active deserves a click to read the alert behind it. Then ask a plain business question of each action: is this a real enquiry? A completed quote form or a phone call from an ad usually is, while a page view, a scroll or a click on a “Contact” button that only opens the form is not.
Next, check which actions are Primary and which are Secondary. Google documents that Primary actions are reported in the Conversions column and used for bidding when the campaign optimizes towards their goal, while Secondary actions are for observation only unless they are part of a custom goal, so a minor action left as Primary can teach Smart Bidding to chase the wrong thing. Look at the count setting as well. Google’s counting page says “Every” is the default for website actions and imports, while the same page suggests that a business generating leads may want to count only one unique lead per ad click, which means a lead form left on the default can report one enquiry as several. Finally, check for the same form being tracked twice, for example by a Google tag and by an imported Analytics key event, with both set to Primary. If you have not tested the tags recently, this walkthrough on how to check that your conversion tracking is working covers the tools and the common failures.

2. Check the settings that spend money quietly
Several Google Ads defaults are designed to widen reach, which is reasonable for some advertisers and costly for a local service business. The first is location targeting. Google’s default and recommended option, “Presence or Interest”, reaches people who are in or regularly in your target area as well as people who have shown interest in it, while the “Presence” option limits ads to people in or regularly in the area. A Calgary plumber who only serves the city usually wants Presence, and Google’s own help page lists “you only want to target users in specific locations” as the case for it. This guide to geographic targeting goes further into radius, exclusions and service-area choices.
The second is the network. Google states that search partners are included by default when you create a Search campaign, and that it does not tell you which partner sites showed your ad unless you run Performance Max. Segment the campaign’s results by network and decide on the numbers whether partners earn their place. The third is automatically applied recommendations. Google lets you choose which recommendation types apply themselves, and they run regularly once switched on, so check the auto-apply settings on the Recommendations page and the change history for edits nobody on your side remembers making. Language settings and ad schedules round out this step, and they take only a minute to confirm.

3. Read the search terms report
The search terms report is where some of the clearest wasted spend becomes visible, because it shows the searches that actually triggered your ads rather than the keywords you bid on. Google notes that it lists terms “used by a significant number of people” and omits low-volume searches for privacy reasons, which means the report may not show every search you paid for. Sort it by cost, and look first at expensive terms with no conversions over your review window, then at terms that are plainly the wrong intent for your business.
For a service business the usual culprits are job seekers, students and people looking to do the job themselves, so terms containing words such as “jobs”, “salary”, “course” or “how to” often deserve a negative, along with places you do not serve, although it is worth reading the full search term before adding a negative, since a phrase like “how to” can also come from someone choosing a provider. When you add negatives, remember that Google states they “won’t match to close variants”, which means a negative for “course” does not block “courses”; plurals and common misspellings need their own entries. Google also supports an account-level negative keyword list that applies to all eligible search and shopping inventory, which is the right home for terms you never want anywhere in the account. If you are starting the list from scratch, this guide to building a negative keyword list shows how to organise it.

4. Review structure, keywords and match types
With tracking trusted and the obvious waste identified, look at how the account is organised. Campaigns should split along lines that need separate budgets or settings, such as service lines with different values or locations with different targeting, and ad groups should hold keywords tight enough that one set of ads can speak to all of them. An account where one ad group holds furnace repair, air conditioning installation and duct cleaning will struggle to show a relevant ad for any of them.
Match types deserve a careful look, because Google documents that broad match is the default match type assigned to every keyword and that it can show ads on searches that do not contain the keyword’s direct meaning. Broad match can work well with Smart Bidding and good conversion data, which is how Google designs it, but in an account with weak tracking or few conversions it tends to drift. Check also for the same keyword sitting in several campaigns, for paused campaigns and ad groups that still hold useful history, and for keywords with plenty of cost and no conversions over the whole window.

5. Check ads, assets and landing pages
Quality Score is useful here as a diagnostic, and only as that. Google states that Quality Score “is not an input in the ad auction” and should not be optimized as a key performance indicator; it is a 1 to 10 summary of how your expected clickthrough rate, ad relevance and landing page experience compare with other advertisers over the last 90 days. Use its three component ratings to find keywords where the ad or the page is weaker than competitors’, because Google’s Ad Rank is based on your bid together with the quality of your ad and landing page measured at auction time, along with Ad Rank thresholds, the competitiveness of the auction, the context of the search and the expected impact of your assets.
Read every active responsive search ad as a searcher would. The headlines should reflect the keywords in the ad group, state what you do and where, and give a reason to choose you, and the description should not repeat the headlines. Check the assets too: sitelinks, callouts, structured snippets, call assets and location assets linked from a Google Business Profile all give the ad more to work with. If the account still relies on call ads, plan the replacement now, because Google stopped allowing new call ads in February 2026 and existing ones stop receiving impressions in February 2027.
Then open each final URL on a phone. The page should match the promise in the ad, load quickly, show the phone number and the form without hunting, and carry the conversion tracking you confirmed in step 1. A strong ad that lands on a generic home page wastes much of its own work.

6. Review bidding and budgets
Check that each campaign’s bid strategy matches what the business wants. A campaign bidding for clicks or impression share when the goal is leads is usually optimizing for the wrong outcome, unless that was a deliberate stopgap while tracking was fixed or data built up, and a Smart Bidding strategy with very few conversions has little to learn from. Google’s own figures help here: it recommends judging Target CPA performance over periods with at least 30 conversions, and it says the “Learning” status can last up to seven days while ads keep serving normally. Any campaign that was on Enhanced CPC deserves a look as well, since Google retired Enhanced CPC for Search and Display in March 2025 and campaigns that were not moved are now effectively on Manual CPC.
Then compare spend with results by campaign. Two patterns matter most. A campaign that is limited by budget and produces real leads at a cost per lead the business accepts is a candidate for more money, and a campaign that takes a large share of the budget with weak results is where money comes from. Device, location and time-of-day segments can refine this, but treat small segments with caution, because a few conversions either way can make a weekday or a neighbourhood look far better or worse than it is.

7. Look at the competition with auction insights
A competitive paid search audit asks who you are up against and whether you are losing ground. The auction insights report answers that inside Google Ads for Search, Shopping and Performance Max campaigns, comparing your results with other advertisers in the same auctions. For Search it gives six statistics: impression share, overlap rate, outranking share, position above rate, top of page rate and absolute top of page rate.
Read it over time rather than as a snapshot. A new competitor appearing with a high overlap rate, or your impression share falling while costs per click climb, explains changes that no setting in your own account will show. Two limits from Google’s documentation are worth knowing: the report shows nothing when your impression share is below 10%, and search partners are not included. For the wider view, including competitors’ ad copy and landing pages, a fuller competitor review fits after the audit rather than inside it.
Turn the findings into a ranked plan
An audit is only as good as the order in which its fixes are made. List every finding, estimate the money at stake for each over your review window, and fix measurement problems before anything else, because they change how every other number reads. After that, stop the waste you can see, and only then move on to growth changes such as new keywords, higher budgets or a new bid strategy.
| Finding type | How to size it | When to fix it |
|---|---|---|
| Tracking is broken, duplicated or counts non-leads | Compare reported conversions with the leads the business actually received | First, before trusting any other number |
| Wrong settings (location, network, auto-apply) | Spend from outside the service area or on partners with no conversions | Right after tracking |
| Irrelevant search terms | Cost of terms with no conversions and the wrong intent | Same week |
| Structure, ads and landing pages | Keywords with weak component ratings and high cost | Over the following weeks |
| Bidding and budget changes | Conversions lost to budget limits, or cost per lead by campaign | Last, one change at a time |
As an illustrative example with invented round numbers: suppose an account spends $3,000 a month, and the audit finds that $400 of it went to job-seeker and do-it-yourself searches, that the main form is counted on “Every” and reports about 20% more leads than the business logged, and that one campaign is limited by budget. The counting fix comes first, because it changes the true cost per lead for every campaign. The negatives come next, because they stop most of that $400 a month from being spent on the same kinds of searches again. Only then does it make sense to move part of that money into the budget-limited campaign and judge the result over a full conversion cycle.
Make changes in batches you can measure, and use Google’s experiments for larger bid strategy changes where you can, so you know which change caused which result. Book a follow-up review once enough new data has come in, which means at least a month and, after a bidding change, at least one to two full conversion cycles, the window Google gives for Smart Bidding to settle.

How often to audit, and who should do it
A common practitioner rhythm for an active account is a full audit every quarter, with lighter monthly checks of the search terms report and conversion statuses, and an extra audit after any big change such as a new website, a new tracking setup or a change of agency. A small, stable account can manage with less, but the search terms report changes every week regardless of how stable the account looks.
You can audit your own account with this checklist, and doing so is a good way to understand what you are paying for. An outside review earns its place when the person who built the account is also the one checking it, because nobody spots their own assumptions easily. If you work with a provider for Google Ads management, ask for the conversion action list, the location and network settings and the last 90 days of search terms, since those three things answer most of the questions in this guide.
SEO Company To-The-TOP! has worked on search in Calgary since 2007 and is Google Ads certified, with one person doing the work from start to finish. If you would like a second opinion on your account, or on an audit you already have, call To-The-TOP! at (403) 308-5949.
Contact Calgary SEO Company To-The-TOP!
Questions about anything in this article, or about your own rankings? Talk to a Calgary SEO specialist directly.
Phone: (403) 308-5949
Address: 1509 14 Ave SW, Calgary, AB T3C 0W4
Hours:
Monday to Friday: 10:00 am – 7:00 pm
Saturday: 12:00 pm – 4:00 pm
Sunday: closed
