Greg Ichshenko

Calgary SEO expert and digital marketing specialist,
developing advertising strategies for businesses of all sizes

(403) 308-5949

greg@to-the-top.ca
1509 14 Ave SW, Calgary,
AB T3C 0W4

    Submit your request or question, and I will get back
    to you shortly

    How to Improve PPC Performance: Find the Metric That Is Failing

    To improve PPC performance, first find the stage where the campaign is failing, then fix only that stage. Confirm that conversion tracking counts real leads or sales, and then read the campaign as a chain: impressions, clicks, conversions and cost per conversion. If the ads are not showing often enough, the problem is budget or Ad Rank. If they show but few people click, the problem is the keywords or the ads. If people click but do not convert, look at the landing page and the offer, and if conversions arrive at the wrong price, look at bidding and targets.

    This guide from SEO Company To-The-TOP!, which has worked in Calgary search marketing since 2007, uses Google Ads for its examples, although the same diagnostic order works on other PPC platforms such as Microsoft Advertising. Each section names the columns to read, what Google’s own documentation says they mean, and the fixes that usually follow. Changing several things at once makes a campaign harder to read rather than better, so the order matters as much as the fixes.


    Illustration of a marketer adjusting four dials labelled traffic, CTR, CPC and conversions

    Check the conversion data first

    Every judgement about PPC performance reads from the conversion column, so start there even if you are sure the problem lies elsewhere. Open Goals, then Conversions, and confirm that each primary conversion action is active and represents something the business values, such as a submitted form, a phone call of a useful length or a completed purchase. A thank-you page that also loads for newsletter sign-ups, or a lead counted twice by a Google Ads tag and an imported GA4 key event, will make a weak campaign look healthy and teach automated bidding to chase the wrong people. If any of this is uncertain, set up conversion tracking properly before you change anything else.

    The second check is timing, and it catches many advertisers out. Google Ads reports conversions against the time of the ad click, not the time the conversion happened, so a lead that comes in on Friday from a click on Monday is credited to Monday. The last few days of any report will therefore look weaker than they really are until the delayed conversions arrive, and judging a change after two days usually means judging it on incomplete data. Google also offers “Conversions (by conv. time)” columns, which report by the time the conversion occurred and make comparisons with GA4 or a CRM fairer.

    Not showing often enough: lost impression share

    If clicks are low, check how often the ads show before you rewrite anything. Impression share is the impressions your ads received divided by the impressions Google estimates they were eligible for, and Google splits the missing share into two columns that point to very different fixes. Search lost IS (budget) is the percentage of time the ads did not show because the budget ran out, and Search lost IS (rank) is the percentage of time they did not show because of poor Ad Rank. Add both to the campaign view, along with Search impression share, and look at them over at least a month.

    A high lost share to budget means the campaign is turning away searches it could have won. You can raise the budget, narrow the keywords or location so the same budget covers fewer searches, or pause the weakest ad groups so the money goes to the ones that convert. A high lost share to rank means the ads are not competitive enough in the auction, and adding budget will not fix that. Google calculates Ad Rank from your bid, the quality of your ad and landing page measured at the time of each search, Google’s Ad Rank thresholds, the competitiveness of the auction, the context of the search and the expected impact of your assets, so the fix is a better bid, a closer match between keyword, ad and page, or both. Google notes that small changes in impression share over time do not necessarily call for action, because the figure is an estimate.

    The auction insights report adds context once you know which problem you have. It shows the other advertisers appearing in the same auctions, with their impression share, overlap rate, outranking share, position above rate and top of page rates. If a new competitor appears with a high overlap rate in the same month your lost share to rank climbed, that is a better explanation than anything inside your own account.

    Showing but not clicked: the keywords and the ads

    When the ads show often but the clickthrough rate is low, check what they are showing for before you blame the wording. The search terms report lists the actual searches that triggered the ads, and a campaign with a weak CTR often turns out to be appearing for searches that were never a good fit, such as job seekers, do-it-yourself research or a different service that shares a word with yours. Adding those as negative keywords lifts CTR because the irrelevant impressions stop, not because the ad improved. Google notes that searches without enough activity are left out of the report for privacy reasons, so a clean-looking report does not prove that all the traffic is clean.

    Illustration of a marketer pruning branches labelled negative from a tree of keywords

    If the searches are right and the CTR is still weak, the ad is the problem. A responsive search ad can hold up to 15 headlines and 4 descriptions, and those slots work best when they say different things: some that mirror the ad group’s main keywords, some that state a concrete detail a searcher cares about, such as the service area or what is included, and some that answer the usual hesitation. Fill in sitelinks, callouts and, where it fits, a call asset as well, because Google counts the expected impact of assets in Ad Rank. Quality Score helps here as a pointer rather than a target. Google describes it as a diagnostic and states that it “is not an input in the ad auction”, but a “Below average” expected clickthrough rate or ad relevance rating is a clear sign that an ad group covers too many themes or that its ads do not reflect its keywords.

    Clicked but not converting: the landing page and the offer

    When clicks are healthy and conversions are not, the ad has done its job and the page has not. Google defines conversion rate as conversions divided by ad interactions, so start by comparing it by landing page and by device rather than for the whole account. A page that takes a large share of the clicks and very few of the conversions is the first thing to fix, because no keyword or bid change will make an unconvincing page convert. Before deciding that a rate is low, it helps to know what a reasonable conversion rate looks like for the kind of lead you are measuring, since a booked call and a brochure download are not comparable.

    The usual faults are easy to see once you look at the page as the searcher does. The heading should repeat what the ad promised, the phone number or form should be visible on a phone without scrolling, and there should be one obvious next step rather than a full site menu. Check the offer as well as the page: if the ad attracts people comparing prices and the page asks for a long form before giving any idea of cost or availability, many will leave, however well the page is built. Landing page experience is also one of the three Quality Score components, so improvements here tend to show up there as well.

    Converting, but at the wrong cost

    If the campaign converts but each conversion costs too much, look at bidding and targeting last, once the earlier stages are sound. Under Smart Bidding strategies such as Target CPA, Target ROAS, Maximize conversions and Maximize conversion value, Google says you do not need manual bid adjustments and that a manual bid adjustment to these strategies “won’t be supported“, although a -100% device adjustment can still turn a device off. Advice to raise bids on weekday mornings therefore applies to manual bidding only, and under Target CPA a device adjustment changes the CPA target for that device rather than the bid itself. With Smart Bidding, the levers are the conversion data you feed it, the target you set, your ad schedule and your location targeting.

    Two pieces of Google’s documentation are worth knowing before you change a bid strategy or target. For Target CPA, Google recommends measuring performance over the last 30 days with at least 30 conversions, which is an evaluation window and not a switch that makes the strategy work, and a campaign with far fewer conversions gives the system less to learn from. Google also says the “Learning” status can show for up to 7 days while ads keep serving as normal, and that updates to budgets, targets or targeting settings never trigger it, although performance takes about a conversion cycle to adjust. There is no need to freeze a campaign for weeks after a small change, but there is good reason to make one change at a time and let a full conversion cycle pass before judging it.

    A worked example in Canadian dollars

    The following figures are illustrative arithmetic, not a Calgary benchmark. Suppose a campaign has an average daily budget of $40, which Google caps at 30.4 times the daily budget over a month, so it can spend up to about $1,216. In a month it buys 400 clicks at an average of $3.00, and 4% of those clicks convert, giving 16 conversions at $75 each. The business wants a cost per conversion of $50.

    There are two ways to get there, and the numbers show which one is realistic. Keeping the click cost at $3.00 and lifting the conversion rate to 6% gives 24 conversions from the same 400 clicks, or $50 each. Keeping the conversion rate at 4% and bringing the average click cost down to $2.00 gives 600 clicks and 24 conversions, also $50 each. If the account’s lost share to rank is high and its Quality Score components are weak, the click-cost route through better ads and pages is the one to try first, since Google says higher quality ads can often lead to lower costs per click. If the ads are strong but the landing page converts poorly on mobile, the conversion-rate route is where the money is.

    Symptoms and where to look

    Symptom Column or report to check Likely fix
    Few impressions, high Search lost IS (budget) Campaign impression share columns Raise budget, or narrow keywords, locations or schedule so the budget covers fewer searches
    Few impressions, high Search lost IS (rank) Impression share columns, auction insights Improve ad and landing page relevance, review bids or targets
    Low clickthrough rate Search terms report, ad and asset performance, Quality Score components Add negatives, split mixed ad groups, write headlines that differ
    Clicks but few conversions Conversion rate by landing page and device Fix the page and the offer; check the form and phone number on mobile
    Conversions at too high a cost Cost per conversion over a full conversion cycle Adjust the target or bid strategy one change at a time; check conversion quality
    Recent days look worse than earlier ones Conversions by click time versus “(by conv. time)” columns Wait for conversion lag before judging a change

    This diagnostic order tells you where a PPC campaign is losing money, and the full optimization checklist covers the routine weekly and monthly work that keeps it from slipping back. Most performance problems sit in one stage at a time, so a fix aimed at the right stage tends to show results within a conversion cycle or two, while a round of changes made everywhere at once can leave you unsure what helped.

    Illustration of a marketer holding a PPC report and an SEO report that both point to results

    If you would like a second opinion on a campaign, or would rather have the work done for you, To-The-TOP! offers Google Ads management from Calgary for businesses in Alberta and British Columbia, and you can call (403) 308-5949 to talk it through.

    Contact Calgary SEO Company To-The-TOP!

    Questions about anything in this article, or about your own rankings? Talk to a Calgary SEO specialist directly.

    Phone: (403) 308-5949
    Address: 1509 14 Ave SW, Calgary, AB T3C 0W4

    Hours:
    Monday to Friday: 10:00 am – 7:00 pm
    Saturday: 12:00 pm – 4:00 pm
    Sunday: closed